My Theological Opinion…

On Original Sin

God commanded Adam, the first man, “You may freely eat of every tree of the garden, but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall die.”(1)

Later, God formed Eve, the first woman.(2)

Still later, though not long after, they were tempted and defied God’s command: She took of its fruit and ate and gave some to her husband…and he ate.(3)
Adam and Eve temptation and disobedience

Original sin refers to this disobedience to God, which, traditionally understood, has universal consequence for all human beings. That is, the corruption of the relationship between the first humans and God, somehow, is transferred naturally, through birth, to all human beings. Thus, original sin, also known as birth-sin, has become a theological abbreviation for the existential human condition of alienation from God.(4)

Original sin oft is differentiated from actual sin; the former being the human state or predisposition of sinfulness and the latter pertaining to human sins or specific voluntary acts that demonstrate (are signs of) human sinfulness.

Original sin, throughout the ages, has been disputed and discredited, primarily because…

Sinfulness is not and cannot be biologically transmitted; therefore, moral disposition is not hereditary, and

The responsibility for sinfulness and sinful acts is individual (that is, relating to each person, each community, each institution, each nation in its own time) and, therefore, cannot be transferred organically from one generation to another, and

The Adam and Eve story is a story; a literary device and not literal history.(5) In a word, it didn’t happen.

Nevertheless, when I read and reflect on the Bible, I do find evidence of original sin, again, defined as our human existential state of alienation from God. For among the Bible’s many themes, whether in the Hebrew scripture story of the covenantal relationship between God and the people Israel or in the New Testament story of the relationship between God and people through Jesus Christ, that is, Christians, there is an unmistakable and proverbial bright red thread of repeated human choosing to reject the divine will and way.

In a word, Adam and Eve don’t prove the existence (the-all-too-alive-and-very-unwell state) of original sin. We do.

 

Footnotes:
(1) Genesis 2.16-17
(2) Genesis 2.18, 20b-23
(3) Genesis 3.6b
(4) This alienation from God, which has manifold expressions, generally speaking, manifests itself in disordered human relationships; individual, societal, and global, e.g., dominant-subordinate and abusive relationships, cultural, ethnic, racial, and gender inequality, war and genocide.
(5) Biblical scholars oft refer to the Adam and Eve story as an etiological legend (etiology: from the Greek, aitiologia; aitia– “cause” + logia– “discourse” or “treatise”); that is, a mythic tale that seeks to explain the origin or cause of something, in this case, sinfulness.

2 thoughts on “My Theological Opinion…

  1. Thank you Paul!!

    Original sin!!! Yes indeed WE DO prove over and over that reject God at times and the way God would like for us to behave. I was probably a teenager before I realized the Adam and Eve story wasn’t true. I wasn’t big on fruit before that!!!

    When I look at the behavior of folks, the last couple of years in particular, it’s stunning how we treat each other. The way we write and speak to each other, the lack of respect for each other. Hard to claim that we are Christians with behavior like this. Yet here were are… and I makes me sad.

    Much love

    Like

  2. Loretta, it occurs to me, in reflecting on your comment, that to know, to believe in original sin – not the Adam and Eve story and not some biological transfer generation-to-generation of guilt, but rather that we humans are predisposed to violate God’s will – places the burden (and, I daresay, the liberty) of repentance precisely where belongs: on each of us. To know and to believe that means that I cannot, I dare not look at anyone other than myself to seek to rectify MY predisposition to violate God’s will. Jesus in his death and resurrection opens the pathway to make that possible. Still, I must take the next…and the next…and the next steps.

    Love

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close